The proposed “adoption” would mimic some of the private adoptions illegally carried out in Ireland up until at least the 1970s. Up to 20,000 false registrations of Irish babies here left them with no trace of their biological history and in some cases, no idea they were ever even “adopted”. Illegal adoptions or illegal birth registrations take place when a child is falsely registered as the biological baby of the adoptive parents. Under Section 2(2) of the Criminal Law (Human Trafficking) Act 2008, these private adoptions carry a maximum penalty of life imprisonment. Domestic and international adoptions into Ireland are overseen by Tusla, which assesses prospective parents while the regulator, the Adoption Authority of Ireland, certifies the placement and provides legal certificates under the Adoption Act 2010. A leading expert in child law here said: “In short, no one should go anywhere near this.” Dr Conor O’Mahony, director of UCC’s Child Care Law Clinic, said there is no such thing as a “private adoption” in Ireland and all adoptions must be approved by the AAI. “Anyone engaging in a transaction of this nature [whether as the purchaser or the seller] would be at risk of prosecution under the legislation prohibiting the sale of children.” The Irish Examiner became aware of several social media pages offering “babies for adoption” online. We engaged with several people who claimed they had children as young as two days old available for adoption. One person told us they had a six-month-old African baby girl and that he was going to “bring the baby over on a boat to Dublin Port” from the UK, where he would “hand over the child”. “It will be very exciting for you, and you can help tell more Irish families about our service,” he said. We engaged with a number of people and asked if they arranged “private adoptions”. One person sent a reply minutes later, saying: “Yes I do, you are looking for a male or female?” The person went on to say they are based in the UK but had been “in contact with Irish families”. “If we want to follow all legal procedures, it’ll cost you about £1,900. But I always like using the other way to make it easier for you.” When we enquired about “the other way” to adopt the baby, the contact said: “Just make arrangements and you come pick them up or I deliver her after I’m done with all the adoption papers. I have a private lawyer for that.” At no point, despite asking repeatedly, did the contact give us details of the “lawyer” they referred to. “Not sure it’s safe” [to say] was the response. “It’ll take about a week [to adopt the baby]” they continued. “Her mom is on board but don’t want to be involved in the process. “First, I’ll need to start with adoption papers. Will work with the lawyer which will cost £250 (€294) to £300 (€353).” When this newspaper asked if we should employ our own lawyer, the person said: “It’s needless getting a lawyer, when everything will be handled. “But you can get your lawyer if you would love to, it just costs you more.” The proposed arrangement included bringing the baby to Dublin Port, where we would meet, and collect the child. It is easier if we come by boat. We will make a birth certificate and you can say the baby is yours. However, when we pressed the contact about the law, and if this was illegal, they stopped correspondence and later blocked us on Messenger. A second engagement with another person led to a conversation about the woman not being able to mind her two-month-old twin girls, and that she would bring them to Dublin. “I’m the birth mother of them,” the person claimed before sending a photo of two babies. “I’m a student and I got pregnant, and the person refused to be responsible of my pregnancy, so I was afraid of abortion, and Idecided to give birth and put them up for adoption. I can’t take care of this alone beside I am a student so I can’t handle this. I am the only child so how will I got out and work to feed them. This is better to adopt them. The person later said it would cost $2,500 (€2,297) to adopt the two babies. The illegal advertising of babies for private adoption online comes amid growing concern, as the number of babies for adoption has declined all over the world in recent years. Research by the Adoption Authority of Ireland shows there were 4,989 intercountry adoptions from abroad approved in Ireland between January 1991 and September 2019. The vast majority of the overall figure took place in the years to October 2010. Of those figures, 83% of these children came from just five countries: Russia, Romania, Vietnam, China, and Ethiopia. Intercountry adoptions From November 2010 to September 2019, there were 707 intercountry adoptions from 23 countries. The decline in inter-country adoptions since 2010 was a direct result of Ireland’s ratification of the 1993 Hague Convention on November 1 that year. New figures also show there were just 102 domestic adoption orders granted in 2022. That includes step parents, long-term foster carers, and infant adoptions, while the authority received 110 applications. Adoptions between Ireland and a large number of countries, including Russia, Ethiopia, and China have all ceased in the past decade due to growing concerns all over the world about baby trafficking. In May, the Netherlands said it will no longer allow its citizens to adopt from foreign countries. Dutch parents adopted around 40,000 children from 80 countries in the previous half-century. There are dozens of similar Facebook pages advertising private adoptions and a quick trawl through them shows some could possibly be a scamming mechanism to lure vulnerable, hopeful parents into the trap of an “adoption” for money. However, one woman, who was illegally adopted in Ireland in 1972 when she was handed to her adoptive parents at three days old through a car window in a car park in Co Louth, said: “Even one baby being trafficked is too much.” Margaret Norton lifted the lid on the criminal behaviour of Dr Irene Creedon in Co Monaghan who was trafficking scores of children all over the country for more than 20 years. She knowingly broke the law by arranging private adoptions and was linked to a number of mother and baby homes, including Bessborough, Temple Hill, and Sorento House in Dublin. Ms Norton, from Co Longford, said: “As an illegally-adopted, illegally- registered, trafficked child of the 1970s I would be horrified to think that in 2024 this alleged trafficking is still ongoing. I was assured by authorities that this would never happen again. Being a product of the above has significant implications on a child’s life, not knowing who you are being the most traumatic. “Not having any paperwork, or in my case falsified paperwork, is so disturbing because even if you are lucky enough to go to a great family like I did, as the years pass you naturally get curious about your birth parents. This illegal practice of moving vulnerable small babies from country to country or within Ireland leaves you with almost no place to start looking for information because essentially you don’t exist. “This is a trauma in a child’s and or adult’s life and can leave people with very profound emotions and feelings. I would urge the relevant authorities such as gardaí to investigate this alleged practice as we certainly do not want history repeating itself for these little babies.” In his report to Government in 2022, the former special rapporteur for children Conor O’Mahony said the State was aware of illegal adoptions in Ireland which happened following the implementation of the Adoption Act in 1952 — a law that was meant to prevent child trafficking. In 2018, Tusla told the Department of Children that at least 126 children adopted through the St Patrick’s Guild Adoption Society had been the subject of an illegal birth registration. That number has since risen to 151. These cases were found when a suspicious marker “adopted at birth” was found on the files in question and investigated. Irene Creedon was not the only high-profile doctor trafficking babies. Consultant Éamon de Valera, the son of the former president, was also involved in the illegal practice. No official figure has ever been determined for the number of illegal adoptions in Ireland, because not all of them have been uncovered. However, an independent review sampled records held by Tusla and the AAI and said there were around 20,000 illegal birth registrations. In a statement, Tusla said it “is not aware of any such adoption practices active in Ireland”. “In the instance such practice comes to light we would report it as a matter of urgency to An Garda Síochána to investigate and the Adoption Authority of Ireland as the regulator of adoption and the central authority under Hague convention, in line with child protection legislation. Anyone with a child protection concern should contact their local duty social work office.” Illegal practice The Department of Children and the Adoption Authority of Ireland said: “Private placements and adoption in Ireland is illegal. “Payment for adoption in Ireland is illegal. Part 15 of the Adoption Act 2010 details the offences and penalties under the legislation for accredited bodies or individuals breaching or failing to abide by the provisions of the Act. “Specifically, Section 144 of the Act prohibits the advertising of adoptions, and Section 145 prohibits the receipt of payments by adopters, parents, or guardians in consideration for the adoption of a child, as well as payments to those who make arrangements for adoptions. “Furthermore, Section 125 prohibits private placements or individuals making such arrangements for the placement and adoption of a child. These restrictions were included in the original Adoption Act 1952.” It added: “Tusla, the Child and Family Agency is the body designated with statutory power to make arrangements for the placement of a child for adoption. The Adoption Authority of Ireland is responsible for regulating and supervising domestic and intercountry adoptions. As both the Competent Authority and Central Authority in Ireland in relation to adoption matters, the authority is the only agency in Ireland that has power under the law to grant or refuse to grant adoption orders. “Adoption can only occur through bodies accredited by the authority. Any prospective parents seeking to or are interested in adopting a child should seek further information from the authority. “The authority is not aware of any Irish families involved in the illegal adoption practices highlighted by the journalist. Furthermore, anyone approached with an offer to arrange an adoption or to arrange an adoption for compensation should immediately report the incident to the gardaí.”
Subscribe
Login
0 Comments
